The freezer doors at some grocery stores have locks on them now. The good liquor sits behind glass. At one California Walmart, even the cheap chubs of ground beef ride to the register inside a metal cage that only a cashier can remove. All that hardware, and the single most stolen food on the planet still sits in an open refrigerated case that most shoppers stroll right past. It’s cheese.
Cheese Walks Out The Door Faster Than Anything Else
A 2011 global retail theft study put the loss at close to 4% of all cheese inventory disappearing through theft every year. That is why security people who study this stuff keep circling back to the dairy case.
The math works in a thief’s favor. Cheese is sealed, compact, and shelf-stable enough to survive a trip out the door in a coat pocket or a purse. The fancy stuff can run as much as $30 a pound, so a single wedge carries the value of a cart full of pasta. Shrink-wrapped and unbranded by the time it changes hands, it’s also close to untraceable.
There’s an actual black market for it. In May 2026, a man in Ontario, Canada was arrested with $1,500 Canadian worth of stolen specialty cheese and chocolate sitting in his car. He had been running a business selling the stolen cheese to other local businesses. On the bigger end, operators have impersonated wholesale buyers and shipping companies to take entire pallets straight from manufacturers, and European crooks smuggle it into Russia to sell at a markup.
Andy Quinn of the UK’s National Food Crime Unit explained the appeal to BBC News: “They know crimes involving food result in less severe convictions than for importing drugs, but they can still make similar amounts of money.” That sentence is the whole business model. A truckload of cheddar pays like contraband and gets charged like a grocery run.
Baby Formula Is The Most Organized Theft In The Store
Formula is bulky and awkward to hide, and it still gets taken constantly, because the buyers are guaranteed. Parents who can’t nurse have no substitute, which makes every can a sure resale.
In September 2026, a man and a woman were arrested and charged in Florida for leading a ring of thieves who pulled formula off shelves at Target, Publix and Winn-Dixie. The thieves were paid $10 a can. The pair stored it and resold it, and investigators traced more than $1.1 million in sales. The ugliest part wasn’t the stolen cans; it was the empty shelves, which the sheriff said can scare parents into stocking up or hunting elsewhere.
Meat Is Why Your Store Has A Cage In The Cooler
Ribeyes, bacon and ground beef are the targets. Prices went up, demand didn’t, and a packaged steak resells fast to someone who doesn’t ask questions, sometimes to a small business and sometimes door to door.
Protecting it is a mess. Meat is bulky, perishable and shaped all wrong for a standard security tag, so grocers have tried nets, safer boxes and AI monitoring at self-checkout with mixed results. One tagging approach reportedly cut losses by 40%. Another chain found the labor cost of applying nets ate up more than the theft did. The California Walmart that locks ground beef in metal mesh is the loud version of the same fight.
Some of it is genuinely ambitious. In 2015, a thief believed to have entered a Washington grocery store through its air ducts left with about $4,000 in goods, including steak, ground beef and chicken.
The $5 Lock On The $6 Pint Of Ice Cream
Frozen food sounds like a strange thing to steal until you think about the packaging. It’s built to be hauled around cold and to survive temperature swings, so it travels neatly under a jacket. Stores in busy areas have responded by locking freezer doors entirely, which means flagging down an employee if you want a bag of frozen peas.
Ice cream is the worst of it. Some supermarkets have gotten desperate enough to clamp $5 plastic lid locks onto $6 pints of premium ice cream, with cashiers popping them off at the register. The economics are almost funny until you’re the cashier doing it forty times a shift, between trips to unlock the freezer case for somebody who wants a frozen pizza.
Top-Shelf Liquor, Coffee And Energy Drinks
Cap locks on bourbon bottles and glass doors over the good Scotch exist because a bottle slides into a backpack and a 12-pack doesn’t. Prestige brands resell easily, and for underage drinkers, stealing is the path that skips the ID check.
Store managers describe liquor theft as constant and unusually brazen. One manager stopped a man strolling past the registers toward the door with more than $1,000 of top-shelf liquor and wine, and figured it wasn’t his first run. Crews show up in groups with empty bags because they know staff can’t physically stop them. Some carry specialized magnets that pop anti-theft devices off bottles.
Coffee lands on the same list for the same reasons: expensive, compact, universally wanted. So do energy drinks and other nonalcoholic beverages, where teenagers get named as frequent culprits and individual stores report them as a real chunk of total losses.
Three In 10 Americans Say They’ve Done It
A LendingTree survey found 30% of Americans admit to shoplifting at least once, up from 23% in 2024. Food and nonalcoholic drinks are the most commonly stolen category at 30%, ahead of clothing, accessories or jewelry at 25% and personal hygiene products at 20%.
Among people who’ve shoplifted, 37% did it within the past year, up from 23% in 2024, and 12% say they do it regularly. Of those who stole in the past year, 90% said inflation and the broader economy played a part. Across everyone who admitted to it, 28% cited financial struggles and 19% said items were simply too expensive to afford.
“These findings are concerning because they suggest many people aren’t shoplifting for thrills or resale, but because they feel squeezed by basic affordability challenges,” said Matt Schulz, LendingTree chief consumer finance analyst.
The income breakdown complicates that. Forty percent of households earning $100,000 or more said they’d shoplifted, compared with 27% of those earning under $30,000. Younger shoppers report it most: 39% of Gen Zers ages 18 to 29 and 38% of millennials ages 30 to 45, against 24% of Gen Xers and 18% of baby boomers.
Grocery Stores Get Hit Hardest, And Walmart Gets Named Most
Grocery stores are the most commonly reported location, cited by 39% of people who admit to shoplifting, ahead of dollar stores at 28% and department stores at 25%. Asked which stores are easiest to steal from, 47% named Walmart, followed by Family Dollar at 21%, Amazon Fresh at 14% and Kroger at 11%.
Most of them get away with it. Fifty-two percent say they’ve never been caught. Among those who were, the most common outcome was a warning at 38%, while 27% were arrested. A quarter of Americans say anti-theft technology doesn’t discourage them, which tells you roughly how much that locked freezer case is accomplishing.
The National Numbers Are Going The Wrong Direction Again
FBI-recorded shoplifting reports across the 50 states rose from 994,652 in 2023 to 1,122,174 in 2024, then fell to 1,069,716 in 2025. That dip still left the country 7.5% above where it was in 2023. Reports dropped in 42 states; eight went up.
Then 2026 turned. Police-reported shoplifting across the cities tracked by the Council on Criminal Justice ran 4% higher in the first half of 2026 than the same stretch of 2025, and 5% above the first half of 2019. Of the 13 offenses examined, shoplifting was the only one still above its 2019 level.
State by state, the spread is wide. Arizona tops a 2026 shoplifting index built by a Texas law firm from FBI data with 30,760 reports in 2025, a figure 41.6% above its 2023 total. California logged the biggest raw volume at 99,591, and New York recorded 71,578. Nevada posted the sharpest jump, up 11.7% to 12,871 reports and 50% above 2023. Idaho sits at the bottom of the index. Capital One Shopping estimates U.S. stores lost $47.8 billion to retail theft in 2025.
What This Actually Costs You At The Register
Cheese takes the title because it checks every box a thief cares about: small, pricey, sealed, wanted by everyone, and gone the second it’s out of the building. Formula draws organized rings. Meat gets the headlines. Cheese has topped the theft studies for years.
The honest cost lands on the people who pay. Locked cases, caged beef and plastic clamps on ice cream lids all mean waiting for an employee with a key, and that employee is already doing three jobs. Sixty-two percent of Americans surveyed figure big corporations can absorb the losses. The checkout line says otherwise.

